Simply Earth vs. Young Living: Best Essential Oils for Diffusion

This is our comparison of Simply Earth vs. Young Living essential oil brands.

I’m an aromatherapy enthusiast who researched what sets these two popular oil companies apart.

Both brands offer a wide selection of pure essential oils. But they have some key differences in oil quality, scents, uses, and pricing.

Young Living features premium therapeutic-grade oils. Simply Earth provides affordable oils great for diffusion.

While both have high quality oils, the best brand for your needs depends on your budget and how you plan to use them.

Let’s dive into the similarities and differences between Young Living and Simply Earth.

I’ll compare oil purity, scent options, intended uses, buying experience, and pricing. My goal is to help you decide which essential oil brand is right for your diffusing needs!

Brand Overviews

Before diving into oil comparisons, let’s start with a quick introduction to each brand.

Young Living

Founded in 1993, Young Living has established itself as a leading name in essential oils and other wellness products. They emphasize their Seed to Seal process which controls quality from the planting of seeds to bottling the final products. Young Living offers a wide range of single essential oils and blends.

young living essential oils logo

Simply Earth

A relative newcomer founded in 2015, Simply Earth focuses on providing affordable, high-quality essential oils sourced from around the world. They are best known for their customizable monthly essential oil subscription boxes. Simply Earth also emphasizes ethical and sustainable practices.

Simply Earth

Now that we’ve covered some background on the two brands, let’s do a detailed comparison of their oils specifically looking at diffusion use cases.

Oil Quality Analysis

One of the most important factors when choosing an essential oil is understanding how pure and high-quality it is. Here is an analysis of Young Living and Simply Earth’s sourcing, production and testing practices:

Sourcing and Production

  • Young Living owns some farms but also sources from partner farms. They emphasize their strict Seed to Seal process.
  • Simply Earth ethically sources oils from small farms around the world. They prioritize sustainable and fair trade practices.
  • Both brands distill oils using low-heat steam distillation to preserve oil integrity.
  • Young Living offers both conventional and organic oil options, while Simply Earth focuses on conventional.

Purity Testing

  • Both brands test oils for purity using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC/MS). This verifies the exact chemical composition of the oils.
  • Young Living does extensive internal testing but does not provide batch-specific GC/MS reports. Simply Earth provides GC/MS reports for each oil batch.
  • Simply Earth also encourages customers to do the freezer test to detect impurities.

Grades of Oils Offered

  • Young Living sells a range of therapeutic grade, food grade and perfume grade oils. Simply Earth focuses on therapeutic grade.
  • Young Living has a Vitality line of oils approved for internal use, while Simply Earth oils are for topical/aroma use.

Overall, both brands offer very high-quality therapeutic grade essential oils that are great options for diffusion. Simply Earth’s transparency and sustainability gives them a slight edge.

Simply Earth vs. Young Living: Best Essential Oils for Diffusion

Top Oils for Diffusion

Now let’s look at some of the most popular essential oils offered by Young Living and Simply Earth for diffusion:

Young Living

  • Lavender: Floral, herbaceous scent, aids relaxation and sleep
  • Lemon: Bright, citrusy aroma, energizing and mood-lifting
  • Peppermint: Cooling minty scent, improves focus and energy
  • Eucalyptus: Strong herbal camphor smell, clears sinuses and congestion
  • Thieves: Spicy cinnamon and clove blend, immune-boosting and cleansing

Simply Earth

  • Lavender: Light floral aroma, stress-relieving
  • Sweet Orange: Tangy citrus scent, uplifting and joyful
  • Peppermint: Invigorating mint scent, improves concentration
  • Eucalyptus: Woodsy, medicinal scent, opens airways
  • Zen Blend: Calming combination including lavender and sweet marjoram

Both brands offer oil options tailored for diffusion with scent profiles perfect for specific vibes – from cozy and relaxing to energizing and revitalizing.

Simply Earth vs. Young Living: Best Essential Oils for Diffusion

Intended Uses

Let’s explore how Young Living and Simply Earth oils can be used in diffusers for different needs:

Relaxation & Unwinding

Both brands have great options like lavender and proprietary blends for winding down. Simply Earth’s Zen Blend and Young Living’s Stress Away are soothing choices.

Energizing & Uplifting

Citrus scents like lemon, grapefruit, and orange are ideal for an invigorating aromatic boost from both brands. Peppermint also enlivens.

Congestion & Stuffy Nose Relief

Eucalyptus, pine, and wintergreen oils from Young Living and Simply Earth can help clear nasal and respiratory congestion.

Concentration & Focus

Oils like peppermint, rosemary, and elemi from both brands provide an aromatic nudge for improved alertness and focus.

Aromatherapy & Wellness

Try Young Living’s Thieves and Simply Earth’s Immunity blend for diffusing with health-supporting properties.

 using diffusers

Both brands have oils suited for relaxation, energy, breathing, concentration, immunity, and more aromatherapy benefits.

Cost Comparison

Pricing is another key factor to weigh when choosing essential oils. Here is a cost breakdown:

  • For equivalent amounts of the same single oils, Simply Earth oils cost 20-40% less than Young Living oils.
  • A 15mL bottle of lavender costs $12.99 from Simply Earth vs $25 from Young Living.
  • Young Living’s most expensive oils include Joy, Immortelle, and Northern Lights Black Spruce, while Simply Earth’s prices have less variance.
  • Simply Earth has an affordable subscription model starting at $39 per month for four oils and recipes.
  • Young Living has a steeper starter kit pricing but offers rewards points with purchases.

Overall, Simply Earth wins out as the more budget-friendly option for most essential oils, especially when purchased via their subscription.

Buying Experience

Let’s quickly cover the shopping experience and customer service provided by each brand:

  • Both have user-friendly websites making it easy to shop for oils. Simply Earth emphasizes subscriptions.
  • Young Living has an extensive educational library. Simply Earth provides some guidance with monthly recipe boxes.
  • Customer service for both brands is generally very responsive and helpful.
  • Simply Earth offers more flexibility with the ability to pause or cancel subscriptions at any time.
  • Young Living has a wider retail presence across stores like Amazon and Walmart.

For most customers, Simply Earth will likely provide an easier and more affordable buying experience, especially if the subscription model appeals to you.

Simply Earth vs. Young Living: What Should You Buy?

Based on our detailed comparison of oil quality, scent profiles, intended uses, pricing, and buying experience, which brand is better for essential oil diffusion – Young Living or Simply Earth?

Both offer high-purity essential oils suitable for diffusing. However, Simply Earth edges out Young Living with:

  • Enhanced transparency with batch-specific GC/MS reports
  • Focus on ethical and sustainable sourcing
  • More budget-friendly pricing, especially via subscription
  • Flexible subscription model without long-term commitments

While Young Living has an edge in brand awareness and product range, Simply Earth wins as the best pick for affordable diffusion oils. Their subscription boxes provide an easy entry point to enjoy these aromatherapy benefits.

Try Simply Earth’s Oils!

Ready to start diffusing? We recommend checking out Simply Earth’s high-quality essential oils and diffusion accessories. Enjoy subscriber discounts and flexibility as you explore the world of aromatherapy!


Q: Are essential oils safe for diffusing?

A: When properly diluted and diffused for short durations, most essential oils are safe. However, some oils should be avoided by children, pregnant women, and pets due to toxicity risks.

Q: How often should I change the water in my diffuser?

A: Change your diffuser’s water daily to prevent mold growth. Use purified or distilled water for best results.

Q: Which oils should never be diffused around pets?

A: Avoid diffusing oils like cinnamon, citrus, peppermint, and pine around pets as they can be hazardous if inhaled. Always diffuse cautiously around animals.

Q: Can I apply essential oils to my skin after diffusing?

A: Yes, oils like lavender and tea tree are safe for topical use after diffusion. Avoid applying oils like eucalyptus directly on skin due to sensitivity risks.