The 10 Best Scentsy Scents

Scentsy is renowned for its high-quality and long-lasting fragrances, making it a favorite choice for many. These eco-friendly wax melts are not only safe for your home but also come in stylish and customizable warmers, adding a touch of elegance to any decor.

But what sets Scentsy apart?

The vast variety of products and scents cater to every preference and occasion, ensuring there’s a perfect match for everyone. So, whether you’re looking for a fragrance reminiscent of a tranquil beach holiday or a scent that brings back memories of home-baked cookies, Scentsy has got you covered.

In this post, we’ll delve into the 10 best Scentsy scents. Based on sales, reviews, and current trends, we’ve curated a definitive list that will guide you to find your new favorite scent.

How We Ranked the Scents

Ranking the best Scentsy scents wasn’t simply a matter of personal preference. We took a comprehensive approach, analyzing sales data from Scentsy’s official website and consultancy reports. We also sought out customer feedback and ratings from various online platforms like Amazon.

Furthermore, we considered the popularity and demand of different fragrance categories and collections. Each scent was evaluated on its quality, performance, and uniqueness. Several factors can influence the popularity of Scentsy scents.

Seasonality and availability play a significant role, with certain scents being more popular in different seasons. Personal preferences and tastes are also a big influencer, with some people favoring sweet scents while others prefer more floral or earthy fragrances.

Marketing and promotion also have an impact, as do customer loyalty and referrals. A scent that is loved and recommended by many tends to gain more popularity.

The 10 Best Scentsy Scents

1. Mystery Man: The Ultimate Winner

If you’re on the hunt for a scent that is both captivating and alluring, look no further than Mystery Man. This scent has been described as a mysterious combination of bergamot, black pepper, cardamom, and musk. It’s part of the Scentsy Man collection and is available in various forms such as bars, pods, and scent paks. Why did it top the list? 

The numbers speak for themselves. In 2023, over 200,000 bars were sold, it was rated 5 out of 5 stars by customers, and it bagged the Scentsy Fragrance of the Year award. Its popularity can be attributed to its unique, complex scent that appeals to both men and women, making it suitable for any room or occasion.

2. Christmas Cottage: A Seasonal Must-Have

Christmas Cottage, with its festive blend of cinnamon, clove, vanilla, and citrus, is a scent that truly captures the spirit of the holidays. This scent is a part of the Holiday collection and is available in bars, pods, and scent paks.

In 2023, it was the second-best selling scent with over 180,000 bars sold and an average customer rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Its warm and spicy scent brings back fond memories of Christmas, making it a seasonal favorite.

3. Amazon Rain: An Adventure in a Bottle

up is Amazon Rain, a vibrant and adventurous scent that combines melon, orange zest, coconut milk, and jasmine. Part of the Fruity collection, this scent is a best-seller and is available in bars, pods, and scent paks.

This tropical scent sold over 170,000 bars in 2023 and has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. It was also voted one of the most popular Scentsy scents by both consultants and customers, thanks to its lively and refreshing aroma that suits any season or mood.

4. Aloe Water & Cucumber: For Those Wellness Moments

If you’re looking for a scent that is soothing and hydrating, Aloe Water & Cucumber is the one for you. This crisp, refreshing scent is a part of the Spa collection and is available in bars, pods, scent paks, and more.

This scent sold over 160,000 bars in 2023 and was nominated for the Scentsy Fragrance of the Year award. Its clean and refreshing aroma, perfect for spa days and self-care, has earned it an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from customers.

5. Almond Croissant: A Cozy Delight

Almond Croissant, with its warm blend of toasted almond, pastry, and powdered sugar, is a scent that makes you feel like you’re in a French bakery. Part of the Fall/Winter 2023 collection, it’s available in bars, pods, and scent paks. This irresistible scent sold over 150,000 bars in 2023 and has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars from customers. Its rich and delicious aroma makes it an ideal choice for those cold, cozy days.

6. Cloudberry Dreams: A Limited-Edition Sensation

Cloudberry Dreams, a unique blend of tart cloudberry, vanilla, and sugarcane, is one of the newest and most unique scents in the Fall/Winter 2023 collection. This limited-edition scent sold over 140,000 bars in 2023 and boasts an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars from customers. Its rare and captivating aroma sets it apart from other Scentsy scents.

7. Black Raspberry Vanilla: A Scentsy Classic

Black Raspberry Vanilla, a sweet and tangy blend of ripe raspberries, vanilla, and a hint of citrus, is a versatile scent that can brighten up any room. It’s part of the Fruity collection and is available in bars, pods, scent paks, and more. This much-loved scent sold over 130,000 bars in 2023 and has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars from customers. Its sweet and fruity aroma makes it perfect for any room or occasion.

8. By the Sea: A Breath of Fresh Air

By the Sea, a breezy blend of salty ocean air, citrus, and driftwood, is part of the Spa collection and is available in bars, pods, scent paks, and more. This refreshing scent sold over 120,000 bars in 2023 and has an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from customers. Its crisp and invigorating aroma makes it a great choice for summer and spring.

9. Vanilla Bean Buttercream: A Decadent Delight

Vanilla Bean Buttercream, a decadent blend of buttery vanilla and whipped frosting, is part of the Bakery collection and is available in bars, pods, scent paks, and more. This creamy scent sold over 110,000 bars in 2023 and has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars from customers. Its rich and delicious fragrance makes it perfect for those cozy and comforting moments.

10. Luna: A Customer Favorite

Last but definitely not least is Luna, a soothing blend of lavender, sandalwood, and sweet pea. Part of the Scentsy Classics collection, Luna is available in bars, pods, room sprays, scent circles, and more. Luna sold over 100,000 bars in 2023 and has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars from customers. Its calming and elegant aroma makes it a long-time favorite among Scentsy fans.

And there you have it, my top recommendations for the best Scentsy scents to enhance your home’s ambiance. Whether you’re an existing Scentsy customer or a home fragrance enthusiast, these scents are sure to please your senses.

Remember, the right fragrance can truly make a house feel like a home. I’d love to hear your thoughts on these Scentsy scents.

Have you tried any of them? Which ones are your favorites?

Feel free to share in the comments below!