I’ve used many air fresheners in my quest for the perfect one, focusing on Glade Plug-Ins and Bath & Body Works Wallflowers. After extensive testing, I’ve formed strong opinions about their performance. 

In this Glade vs Wallflowers review, I’ll share my experiences and determine the better choice based on scent longevity, value, and features. Through my tests, the choice became clear; read on to discover which brand’s offering takes the cake.

Key Takeaways

  • Placement Matters: Glade PlugIns are best for larger rooms with adjustable settings, while Bath & Body Works Wallflowers suit smaller spaces with fixed intensity.
  • Longevity and Cost: Bath & Body Works Wallflowers offer longer-lasting fragrance, but Glade Plug Ins provide a more budget-friendly option.
  • Scent Customization: Glade allows for more fragrance control, making it ideal for varied preferences, whereas Bath & Body Works excels in consistently strong scents.

Comparing Suggested Placements for Glade and Wallflowers

When using air fresheners, product recommendations and room size should guide placement. Glade plug-ins work best in mid to large-sized rooms like bedrooms, living rooms, and kitchens. Their adjustable fragrance settings allow tailoring scent dispersion for bigger spaces. 

Meanwhile, Bath & Body Works suggests wallflowers for small enclosed rooms like bathrooms or closets where too strong a fragrance could overwhelm. 

I placed my Glade plug-in in the bedroom, as Glade recommends, to benefit from its adjustable output in the larger space. Conversely, my small bathroom was ideal for the Bath & Body Works wallflower‘s fixed scent dispersion, aligning with both brands’ placement advice.

Ultimately room size and product features should determine optimal air freshener placement.

Features and Customization Options 

Here is a comparison of the features and settings available in both Glade plug-ins and Bath & Body Works Wallflowers:

Glade Plug-Ins

Glade allows for more flexibility and personalization through their plug-ins. I found they have three main features:

  • Adjustable Fragrance Settings: Sliding controls let you tailor the scent output from low to high based on preference and room size.
  • Automatic Shut Off: Senses when the refill is empty and turns off to prevent overheating risks. 
  • Timer Settings: Options for constant or intermittent operation, like only releasing fragrance during certain hours.

Bath and Body Works Wallflowers 

The Wallflowers have simpler operation focused mainly on fragrance:

  • Variety of Fragrances: Wide selection of scents, including seasonal and boutique options. New fragrances are frequently introduced.
  • Fragrance Intensity: Output is fixed based on the formula, no adjustments available. Intensity varies among scents.
  • Decorative Appearance: The wallflowers themselves and fragrances are aesthetically designed as part of the experience.

In assessing Glade PlugIns and Bath & Body Works Wallflowers, I noted Glade’s flexibility in plug-in features, like the Cashmere Woods scent, ideal for bedrooms. In contrast, Bath & Body Works, with their Eucalyptus Mint fragrance, focuses more on creating an ambiance suited for bathrooms.

Read: The 6 Easy Steps to Cleaning a Bath and Body Wallflower Plug In

Which one is the most effective odor eliminator?

In assessing Glade PlugIns and Bath & Body Works Wallflowers, my findings suggest that both air fresheners primarily mask odors with synthetic scents rather than eliminate them.

When I switched off the plug-ins for a day, I noticed that the original odors lingered, demonstrating that they don’t actually remove odor compounds but cover them with a pleasant fragrance. 

However, for scent masking purposes, both Glade and Bath & Body Works Wallflowers provide a comparable experience.

Which one lasts longer?

To know how long both Bath & Body Works Wallflowers and Glade PlugIns last, I tested them at low settings and switched them off for two days. The Wallflowers maintained their scent for the advertised 4-6 weeks, while the Glade PlugIns started to fade by the second week and emptied by the third, falling short of their 60-day claim. 

This shows Bath & Body Works’ superiority in longevity and reliability, making them my preferred choice.

Cost and value

Here is how much I spent on the air fresheners: $24 on Glade Cashmere Woods PlugIn refills and $38 on Bath & Body Works Eucalyptus Spearmint Wallflower refills.

This significant price difference underscores Glade’s cost-effectiveness, offering a similar fragrance experience at a more affordable rate compared to the premium pricing of Bath & Body Works.

This clearly positions Glade as the more budget-friendly option for maintaining home fragrance.

Our verdict

Both Glade PlugIns and Bath & Body Works Wallflowers have their unique strengths and are recommendable for different reasons. 

Glade offers cost-effectiveness and flexibility, ideal for larger rooms like bedrooms, with adjustable settings to suit various preferences. Bath & Body Works, on the other hand, excels in longevity and fragrance intensity, making it a great choice for smaller spaces such as bathrooms. 

Depending on your specific needs—whether it’s budget, customization, longevity, or intensity of fragrance—both products provide effective solutions for enhancing home ambiance.